Ranking the Greatest US Golfers of All Time

When it comes to golf greatness, America has produced more than its fair share of legends—players who didn’t just dominate the PGA Tour, but reshaped the game itself. From early pioneers to modern icons, this list ranks the 25 greatest U.S. golfers of all time, based on major wins, career longevity, influence, and unforgettable moments. And while this list focuses on fully established careers, names like Scottie Scheffler are rapidly climbing into the conversation. With two Masters wins and a stretch of dominance rivaling Tiger’s prime, Scheffler could soon demand a place among the all-time greats if his current trajectory continues.

#25. Lee Trevino

Career Snapshot: Trevino amassed 29 PGA Tour wins, including 6 major victories—twice each at the U.S. Open, The Open Championship, and once the PGA Championship—across a win span from 1968 to the mid-1980s.

Legacy: A charismatic and gritty Texan, “Supermex” became known for his patient course management, iconic underdog persona, and incredible comebacks. He inspired a generation of players with his ability to rise under pressure and helped grow golf’s popularity among Latino and working‑class fans.

#24. Phil Mickelson

Career Snapshot: With 45 PGA Tour wins and 6 major titles—including three Masters, a PGA Championship, and a U.S. Open—Mickelson has been a major presence since the early 1990s.

Legacy: Lefty reshaped perceptions of left-handed players in golf, known for his daring shot-making and longevity. His rivalry with Tiger Woods, epic near-misses at the U.S. Open (six runner-up finishes), and dramatic career resurgence—including winning the 2021 PGA Championship at age 50—solidified his place in history.

#23. Davis Love III

Career Snapshot: Davis Love III secured 21 PGA Tour victories, including the 1997 PGA Championship, and spent over 450 weeks in the world’s top 10 during the 1990s and early 2000s. He was also a two-time Ryder Cup captain and a consistent team leader throughout his career.

Legacy: Known for his elegant swing and poise, Love was a cornerstone of American golf’s consistency era. Beyond his playing career, he made a huge impact as a captain, mentor, and course designer. His long tenure near the top of the sport—and enduring popularity among fans—make him a worthy addition to the Top 25 list.

#22. Gene Sarazen

Career Snapshot: Sarazen logged 38 PGA Tour victories and 7 major championships, including winning the career Grand Slam long before it became rare in modern golf.

Legacy: An innovator who invented the modern sand wedge and helped define golf’s golden era, Sarazen became a broadcasting pioneer and global ambassador. His “shot heard ’round the world”—a double eagle in the 1935 Masters—remains lore.